EPALE discussion: The role of media literacy in adult learning
As part of our September focus, EPALE is organising a written discussion on the role of media literacy in adult learning.
The discussion will take place on this page on 27 September at 10:00 CEST and will be moderated by EPALE Thematic Coordinator Markus Palmén. Don’t miss the opportunity to share your views and experiences with the EPALE community on any of the following topics:
10:00-12:30 CEST Media literacy as a concept Media literacy is a cross-disciplinary field of research and education, which is commonly understood to encompass accessing media, analysing and evaluating media content, and actively creating media content.
Discussion left open during lunch interval
13:30-16:30 CEST European practices of media literacy education for adults
Share interesting practices and initiatives of media literacy for adults in your country. What is being done, how, to what kind of impact? Share concrete examples. |
** Comments will be open on 24 September so participants can introduce themselves or post their opinions in advance.
Kumment
Some examples
Finnish examples
Erasmus+ Projects promoting media literacy
Dear Angelo, in June 2017 we held a national EPALE Conference in Austria "Digital Participation. Digital literacy for participation in the society of the future" where the connection of digitalization and adult learning was discussed from various angles. Challenges for students and teachers in ICT within basic skills training, opportunities offered by MOOCs for adult educators, … - in the publication you will find examples of best practice Erasmus+ projects: Adults acquiring digital skills – insights into the Finnish approach and the results of the Erasmus+ project Digi4Adults (this project was already mentioned today), or SOLA – Simple Open Learning Advancement focussing on ICT in work based learning and many more.
When
searching for impact we should also look at the opportunities offered by
Erasmus+ Adult Education KA1 to benefit from mobility experience across Europe
and encourage adult education institutions to participate and benefit.
I would like to mention the KA 1 project “Digitising adult education and raising
the media literacy of educationally disadvantaged women”, co-ordinated by abz*austria (www.abzaustria.at), an
"organisation which promotes the work, education and future of women.
Female employees from abz*austria were visiting various institutions in Denmark
and Germany with the aim of learning new digital training and guidance methods
and improving the digital skills of their trainers and advisers. They were
looking at the use of online tools for assessing skills in education guidance
at the institutions they visit or learning about the measures that are taken to
improve the digital skills of educationally disadvantaged women and older
people. As an impact abz *austria gained valuable knowledge about good-practice
methods and models which can then be incorporated when developing their own
courses". (see the above mentioned conference publication)
Careers guidance counsellors for adults are also faced with the challenges and opportunities of ICT. Please find several good practices exhibited at the following Euroguidance conference "Guidance 4.0 - New Tools and Skils in Education and Careers Guidance" . Several Erasmus+ Projects are to be found in Annex III page 85 ff of the conference publication.
Hi Eva, thank you very much
Code of ethics
Definition of the media literacy
difficult one
Citizens journalism vs pros
Absolutely
Media literacy and adult education
Media Literacy and Academic Research
Hello my name is Klaudius Silhar and I am from Slovakia. I would like to draw the attention of academics to the journal Media Literacy and Academic Research (double-blind peer-reviewed journal published twice a year). The journal is international and interdisciplinary, inviting contributions from across the globe and from various academic disciplines of social sciences. The Journal Publishes in both print and online version.
It focuses on theoretical and empirical studies, research results, as well as papers related to the new trends, practices and other academic research areas. Also encouraged are literature reviews, innovative initiatives, best practices in online teaching, institutional policies, standards and assessment. The Journal welcomes the submission of manuscripts that meet the general criteria of significance and scientific excellence.
The journal is now indexed with and included in Ulrich’s Periodical Directory, CEEOL, CEJSH, Scientific Indexing Services(SIS) and ResearchGate. Moreover the journal is under the indexing process with Scopus, ERIH Plus, Cabell ́s Directories, Index Copernicus, ProQuest, EBSCO and Emerging Sources Citation Index(ESCI) – Web of Science Core Collection.
The members of the journal ́s Editorial Board are members of the European Communication Research and Education Association (ECREA), UNESCO-UNAOC UNITWIN Network for Media and Information Literacy, European Association for Viewers Interests (EAVI), The Slovak EU Kids Online Team, Media Literacy Expert Group and International Association for Media Education (IAME).
Hello Klaudius
Obstacles in media literacy
Hello everybody. My name is Martin Dobes and I am from the Czech EPALE team. Of course, media literacy is a hot topic in my country – as well as in majority of all EU countries.
I agree with what has been said regarding the need to change the definition of „media literacy“ so that it covers the fact that we all are now creators of media content. Actually, the speed with which media change is so dynamic that we will have to adapt the definition of the term constantly in the future.
However, this is not – as I see it – the main problem. When we speak about school education, media literacy is a part of curriculum in primary and secondary education as a cross-theme in the Czech Republic (and in many other countries), but in reality schools are not quite prepared to dig deep enough as they should and reflect the peculiar problems of hoaxes, fake news etc. Teachers are often afraid to reflect most recent developments, social or political, as they fear rejection or they themselves need more support in the field. And as for adults? There is a basic trouble here. Medially illiterate person does not know about his/her incompetence – quite contrary. What we lack completely is the motivation to learn (among those who need it). And we lack techniques to stimulate the motivation.
There is the other side of the coin – and this would be typical for former Eastern-Block EU countries. Spreading disinformation and hoaxes has unfortunately become a hidden tool of political struggle to such an extent that it is actually not in the interest of certain political parties and movements (and in some cases even state institutions) to address the issue.
A very vulnerable target group here are senior citizens. Prior to presidential elections in the Czech Republic, tens of thousands of old people had been systematically sent emails with various misleading content. And many of them have sent them further on so that it circled the whole country in huge numbers.
Great points
Media literacy and young media professionals
Media Literacy as a challenge for AE
Flemish knowledge center on Media Literacy
I'm Karine Nicolay of the EPALE NSS in Belgium/Flanders and I wanted to tell you about 'Mediawijs'. Mediawijs is the Flemish Knowledge Centre for Digital and
Media Literacy at imec vzw on the initiative of the Flemish Minister for Media. We aim to help the citizens of the Flemish community in Flanders and Brussels
to use ICT and media consciously, critically, actively and creatively to
participate in society.
To that end Mediawijs sets up consultation, networks and cooperation with and
between the Flemish digital and media literacy field, inspires the Flemish digital and media literacy field
with training, sharing knowledge and developing practice, stimulates citizens to acte digital and media literate with
information and campaigns, keeps tab on all things ICT & media and digital and
media literacy, plays an active role in developing policy on digital and
media literacy in Flanders, Brussels and Europe.
There's a web page in English about Mediawijs: https://en.mediawijs.be/
But most of the materials can be found on the Dutch page: https://mediawijs.be/
Critical Media Literacy
Good morning from EPALE NSS Austria!
Media literacy has been receiving much attention when working with children and
adolescents here in Austria, and we are also witnessing an increasing awareness of the need to
promote media literacy for all age groups. As for the definition above: it is helpful
to describe Media Literacy not only in a technical terms, but also to point to the
notion of critical thinking as a core component of critical media literacy.
Just to give an example of the actitivies here: In October
2018 a lecture series “Critical Media Competency in
Political Adult Education” (held in German) is set by the Austrian Society for Political Education in cooperation
with COMMIT, Depot and VHS Mariahilf, focussing on topics such as critical media analysis and hate speech on social
networking sites (SNS).
I will be joining the discussion in the afternoon again, looking forward to todays discussion!
Critical thinking is essential
Hello / presenting a project on political issues and arts
Welcome to the discussion!
Critical thinking
media literacy and critical thinking
European practices of media literacy education for adults
1. Is media literacy a topic of public debate in your country? Is it e.g. discussed in connection with the term of “fake news”? Is it a political topic? Give examples of the debate in your country.
In Portugal, discussions about the relevance of media literacy are more frequent and begin to address the issue of fake news.
In December 2017, the Parliamentary Committee on Culture, Communication, Youth and Sports of the Republic Assembly held an international meeting entitled "Media pluralism in Europe and Portugal". In May of the same year, the Faculty of Social Sciences and Humanities of the New University of Lisbon organized a conference called "Fake news and algorithms", addressing editorial responsibility and freedom of expression in the online world.
Thus, the subject has been discussed mainly in the political and academic domains and considered as transversal theme that any education and training provider can develop in its practices of education and training.
In our country, there is a reference of education for the media for pre-school education, basic education and secondary education, since April 2014. This material is available at http://www.dge.mec.pt/sites /default/files/ficheiros/referencial_educacao_media_2014.pdf
This issue is seen as part of Education for Citizenship and it is a subject of Directorate-General for Education responsibility. This reference clarifies in its foreword that "media literacy implies the ability to understand - or critically read - the media and the social and cultural processes through which images and representations of the world in which we live are presented, using different images ". And, "critically reading the media" is "being able to recognize and value what contributes to the broadening of horizons, to knowledge of what is happening in the world, to the reception of the diversity of values and worldviews and to the construction of identities ".
Although it is seen as a lifelong learning process, the referential clarifies that formal basic education is "a decisive step".
In the field of adult education and training, including the recognition and certification of prior learning, there are two referents that are used by Qualifica Centres professionals and by adult teachers and trainers: one for basic level of education and other for secondary level of education.
Both include contents related to literacy media. The referent for basic level has a domain entitled “Language and communication”, which can be worked with adults throughout media contents, as news, advertising, opinion articles.
The reference to the secondary level of education addresses the theme of media literacy in three of its four areas of competence, namely “ICT”, "Society, technology and science" and "Culture, language and communication". Therefore, adults who perform competency recognition processes or who attend training courses will, at the end of training, demonstrate evidence of competencies related to the following issues: the impact of the media on building public opinion; the evolution of technological networks and social networks; the importance of the media in the creation of media power; the impact of the Internet and the development of a critical attitude towards the contents available there.
2. What do you think are the media literacy skills most needed by European adults in 2018? Do you think adult’s media literacy education should differ from that of children or young people? How?
Media literacy has to be transversal and should happen throughout life, because, as is well known, media themselves have been changing and suffering many influences generated by society and industrial changes.
Today, media literacy cannot be limited to the ability to interpret contents, it must go further.
Today there are two new problems that people need to be aware of. The first is that we are no longer just news consumers. Today, anyone can also be a content producer. This is a positive thing, because it has democratized access to the media, giving voice to all people, but it is also a negative thing because everyone can broadcast contents and there is no way to control the veracity of what is disseminated, particularly in social networks. Therefore, in order to distinguish between what can be credible and what cannot, we must have access to a much more solid knowledge of our reality and the contexts in which we act and live.
The second problem is related to the track we all leave whenever we emit our likes and interests or whenever we do Internet searches. We must be aware that everything we do is mapped out and can be used for commercial and other purposes that we cannot control. That is why we need to be careful with how we use the media and in particular social networks.
In addition to enabling the use of media, understanding them and even creating contents, media literacy should also promote awareness to these two problems.
As adult learning effectiveness depends on been pragmatic and applied to adults concrete life situations it must be different from those for children and young people.
Arvien vairāk cilvēki sāk
Media literacy as a concept
1 – Do you find the above definition of media literacy useful, or is it lacking some elements? What is most important? What would you emphasise, remove or add?
The definition presented focuses only on the contents and does not mention the media and their specificities.
Today, the media itself are extremely relevant because it determines and condition the contents. This is evident in the field of social networks. In addition, it is necessary to take into account a set of assumptions in the interpretation of the contents that result from the medium. For instance, a citizen does not need to have certain precautions or suspicions about the veracity of the contents if he or she is reading a newspaper or even watching a channel from a news agency, but this is no longer the case if the message is served by a created network among friends, however honest and close these friends may be.
People need to be aware of it. A recent study by a Portuguese scientist team that has been released in march has shown that the opinions we proclaim in social networks have repercussions, with the three-degree influence rule. It means that what I affirm generates influence in my friend, in the friend of this friend and still in the friend of his/her friend. There is a social influence at distance.
2. Do you think different types of media require different types of media literacy skills for adults to evaluate content? For example, does analyzing a piece of art require different skills than evaluating the content of a news website? What might these different skills be?
The ability to interpret and even question any content depends, first of all, on the level of literacy of each person. Obviously, a person who lacks basic skills is hardly able to interpret a piece of art in the same way as another who has a higher literacy level.
The capacity of interpretation of any media is still related to the context and the referents that we have. This is referred in Marshall MacLuhan's book “The Gutenberg Galaxy”, written about the emergence of writing and typography. Today, in most civilizations and cultures, people already live in the Marconi Galaxy, but those who do not have digital skills still live in the Gutenberg Galaxy.
We all need referents to interpret the world and to understand the meaning of things.
Nowadays it is not enough to read or write, nor to have a basic command of ICT. We need a little more and, as a new industrial age emerges, we need to develop new skills associated with code, data analysis and logical thinking.
Dissemination and exploitation of Erasmus + project results