chevron-down chevron-left chevron-right chevron-up home circle comment double-caret-left double-caret-right like like2 twitter epale-arrow-up text-bubble cloud stop caret-down caret-up caret-left caret-right file-text

EPALE - Plateforme électronique pour l'éducation et la formation des adultes en Europe

Blog

(In)visible hand - support for seniors citizens during a quarantine

11/05/2020
par Nina Woderska
Langue: EN
Document available also in: PL ES EL

[translated from Polish original version]

Did you know that the pain of social rejection – resulting, for example, from exclusion - activates the same areas in the brain as physical pain? Why is this the case? According to David Eagleman, a neurobiologist, it happens so because social ties are very important to humans. According to Eagleman, the pain pushes us towards forging bonds with others. We form bonds because we need them. [1] So how does a person behave and what can one feel in isolation? Fear, uncertainty, panic, loneliness? Does it sound familiar?

The world is shaking, so each one of us is trying to maintain mental balance and come to grips with this new reality. Specialists in several areas of expertise are looking into changes resulting from the current situation. You can review Piotr Maczuga's (EN) thoughts on education in a time of crisis and opportunities for distance learning. Thanks to the synthesis prepared by Radek Czahajda, you can learn about the tools and means to organise online training and make it interactive. I recommend reading both texts.

 

However, my attention has been drawn to grassroots activities of the society, which involve volunteering (called by some as a service or support activities), addressed to people in their late adulthood. On a micro-scale, it is voluntary work performed for a cohort forming a specific age group. On a macro scale, civic education is constantly on my radar.

Probably, each of us has already heard and knows very well that it is elderly people with weakened immunity, who are suffering from co-existing diseases, especially chronic ones, who are in the group with the highest risk of coronavirus infection and falling ill with COVID-19. To them, contact with other people who are or potentially could be infected is the most dangerous. Their physical and also, in my opinion, mental health is at risk.

 

   

Recommendations issued by the Chief Sanitary Inspector addressed to senior citizens include, among other things, limiting their presence in public places. Out of the concern for their health, they should not leave their homes (if possible) and should limit all forms of activity requiring mobility to a minimum. Other recommendations point to limiting contact with young people (i.e. grandchildren), who may pass on the disease, even though they may not exhibit typical symptoms.[2] Isolation from other members of society, especially from one's own family can be extremely challenging for senior citizens. Asking others for help (in the face of danger and fear) in everyday activities, such as shopping, buying medicine, dealing with administrative matters, does not always come easily to an elderly person.

That's why when I hear someone saying that thanks to the current situation they will acquire solidarity-driven cooperation competence, I have to object. In my opinion, it is not about to be acquired, as it has been visibly manifesting for some time now. Voluntary activities for the elderly and those in need (and others!) offered by the rest of the society - i.e. activities based on voluntary, unpaid, and intentional work for the benefit of other people or society as a whole, which goes beyond family and friendship relationships, was noticeable very quickly. Help and support offers appeared sooner than requests for them. It is very heartening and it reflects the great power that lies in volunteering. It also proves the need for civic education, both at a time of crisis and beyond it.

There are a lot of examples of neighbour's help i.e. information placed on staircases, where neighbours offer other residents (seniors and people in need) to do shopping or take a dog for a walk. This idea - not only in Poznań - although I will use my city as an example - has also been introduced by the authorities of many cities; in Poznań, PL it operates as the "Shopping for Seniors" initiative.[3]

Emergency shopping is not the only way to help seniors citizens. The urge to mentally support people in late adulthood has also been recognised. The need for action in this area is not new, it did not come with the outbreak of a pandemic. So-called "trust or friendships lines" i.e. distant support services have already been in place.

In February this year, my attention was drawn to the information about the creation of Halofon - a grass-root initiative of senior citizens of Łódź, Poland, who decided to provide such distant support to a dozen or so people in late adulthood, who do not leave home due to loneliness or dysfunction. How did this happen? As the vice-president of the city said, the seniors themselves noticed such a need and found a source of funding to be able to create a "Halofon". [4]

In March, however, I observe (with joy) development of the new services dedicated to senior citizens. There are organizations (such as the Poor Brothers' Association) that are increasing the number of hours of telephone support [5], and there are those that are starting their telecare right now: for example TelefonPogadania.pl or "Two phones to Grandma". In the former, the idea is to network the volunteers who would like to support by a phone call the lonely elderly. The volunteers can be called by people who do not have anyone else close to them to call. [6] In the other initiative, the emphasis is placed on family telecare - on the keeping in touch by the members of the seniors' family, including grandchildren. "Let it be regular phone calls, at a certain time, so that the seniors have the feeling that they are being taken care of" - ask the organizers of the action. [7]

Institutions and organisations also share with seniors their resources on the Internet. They make their materials, articles, broadcasts and reports available free of charge. [8].

However, there are also those seniors who do not follow the recommendations. Why is that? Maybe they're just feeling the pain that David Egelman is writing about? Maybe no one has yet called them asking about their health and well-being, no one has offered support or shown alternative forms of activity? Or maybe the reasons are quite different?

Psychology describes a phenomenon associated with the dispersion of responsibility (also known as the diffusion of responsibility, the spectator effect or the effect of an indifferent passer-by), which reduces the probability of responding to a crisis event as the number of witnesses to that event increases. Are we in a crisis situation? Do we have any influence on whether there will be a dispersion of responsibility in society? In my opinion, both answers remain the same.

     

dr Nina Woderska– a pedagogue, the lecturer at the Higher School of Health Science and Personnel Education School, the employee of the Center for Senior Initiatives in Poznań and the coach at the Association for Development of Civic Education CREO.

   

    

[1] D.Eagelman, Mózg. Opowieści o nas, Zysk i S-ka Wydawnictwo, Poznań 2018.

[2] https://gis.gov.pl/aktualnosci/informacja-glownego-inspektora-sanitarnego-dla-seniorow/

[3]https://www.poznan.pl/mim/info/news/seniorko-seniorze-ponawiamy-prosbe-zostancie-w-domu,144977.html

[4]https://uml.lodz.pl/aktualnosci/artykul/halofon-seniorzy-sami-napisali-projekt-zdobyli-dotacje-iwspieraja-lodzian-60-id32907/2020/2/13/?fbclid=IwAR1ey0zP8bdJTQrzDnwwPFmM7DhKLRZgI-xlyXxWLQhqn4t9RJV4HqSer3c

[5] https://www.malibracia.org.pl/

[6] https://telefonpogadania.pl/

[7]https://poznan.naszemiasto.pl/koronawirus-w-polsce-atakuje-akcja-dwa-telefony-do-babci/ar/c14-7595047?fbclid=IwAR1H8-MqLN_DNg53z1DiDxpZTxQXgJ0ZY3UlZWQMI--RWsP4pr15BiLNA-Q

[8]https://60virtualculturepl.blogspot.com/2020/03/gimnastyka-poranna-dla-seniorow.html?fbclid=IwAR3YyvHtI89qC7A-epNIZRZFAVPik_Z6V8P8y2M8HlE60_pVg83NSpBMDOk

 

 

 

 

 

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Epale SoundCloud Share on LinkedIn Share on email
Refresh comments Enable auto refresh

Affichage 1 - 8 sur 8
  • Portrait de Signe Gotfridsone
    Es ļoti priecājos par to, ka tiek organizētas dažādas brīvprātīgo grupas, kas palīdz cilvēkiem gados gan sagādāt ēdienu, gan izdarīt citus nepieciešamos darbus. Kā jau zināms, pensionāri ar dažādām blakus slimībām ir vislielākajā saslimšanas riska grupā, tāpēc mums, jauniešiem, būtu jāpalīdz cik vien ir mūsu spēkos, lai viņi izvairītos no inficēšanās ar COVID- 19. 
  • Portrait de Nina Woderska

    Thank you for reading the text and your comment. I am also glad that there are so many activities supporting seniors during pandemic. I am very curious what activities for seniors are organised in your country. I will wait for your comments :) Greetings

  • Portrait de David LOPEZ
    Me parece este tema absolutamente imprescindible. Las primeras victimas del COVID 19 son los ancianos. Lo que el articulo presenta son las iniciativas que responden a carencias evidentes de relacion social, de reconocimiento. El tema de la comunicacion esta mencionado. Me parece que tambien existe un tema no suficiamente tratado, es el desequilibrio digital y nuevas formas de exclusion social por el hecho de quedarse fuera del mundo digital. De hecho los mayores sufren asi una nueva exclusion posible. Encontrar soluciones rapidas par acompanar a los mayores en estos nuevos territorios es necesario. David LOPEZ
  • Portrait de Nina Woderska
    Muchas gracias por leer y comentar mi texto. Me alegro que la información sobre lo que está sucediendo en Polonia en el área de apoyo a los mayores durante la pandemia haya llegado a España. Como usted ha señalado correctamente, no mencioné el tema de la participación de las personas mayores en el mundo digital. Contrarrestar la exclusión digital es un gran desafío en Polonia. En mi ciudad hay un teléfono de asesoramiento digital para personas mayores con el que yo también trabajo.  Aunque hay preguntas, por ejemplo sobre el uso avanzado de mensajeros, la mayoría de las personas mayores hablan sobre la falta total de habilidades y el miedo a usar el ordenador, Internet o un teléfono táctil. Este tema ciertamente vale una tema aparte. Gracias por la idea. 
    Saludos
  • Portrait de Monika Hausman-Pniewska
    To wspaniałe, że ludzie tak empatycznie zareagowali, zresztą nie miałam wątpliwości, że tak będzie. Bardzo dużo tych ofert pomocy umieszczana jest jednak w internecie, a choć seniorzy całkiem sprawnie posługują się FB, to ci najstarsi już nie są tacy biegli i taka forma pomocy do nich nie trafia. W Olsztynie też uruchomiliśmy różnego rodzaju wsparcie naszych najstarszych uczestników: od porad psychologicznych do możliwości zrobienia zakupów i telefonowania właśnie. Namawiamy, aby rozejrzeć się wokół siebie, czy w sąsiedztwie mieszka ktoś samotny lub potrzebujący pomocy i takie osoby zgłaszać.  Osobiście obdzwoniłam kilka sąsiadek i za każdym razem słyszałam, że mają kogoś z rodziny, kto im pomoże, ale były bardzo wdzięczne za telefon i zainteresowanie. 
  • Portrait de Nina Woderska
    Dostałam ostatnio wiadomość od mojej znajomej: "Wczoraj dzwoniła do mnie znajoma, wiekowa pani, która czując się samotna wybierała numery w telefonie na chybił trafił, żeby tylko z kimś porozmawiać. Mieszka sama, teoretycznie jest zaopiekowana przez rodzinę, ale brakuje jej rozmowy z drugim człowiekiem." 
    Tak wiele możemy zrobić przez tak niewiele...
  • Portrait de Nina Woderska
    Zgadzam się - technologia nie jest barierą dla seniorów ( o ile zostaną odpowiednio wprowadzeni w cyfrowy świat - dopowiem) 

    Wzmocnię się (nasze wspólne zdanie) wynikami pochodzącymi z raportu Związku Banków Polskich z tego roku: "osoby starsze są coraz bardziej aktywne w przestrzeni cyfrowej. Aż 59% pytanych wskazuje, że kontakt z bankowością nie sprawia im, żadnych problemów, a 80% seniorów korzystających z internetu zadeklarowało, iż zarządza swoimi finansami poprzez bankowość mobilną lub internetową." :)
  • Portrait de Sławomir Łais
    Myślę, że oddolne działania mają zawsze w sobie pierwiastek prawdziwości - wszak pojawiły się bez żadnego namawiania, czy przymuszania, urodziły się same. Głęboko wierzę w takie inicjatywy, sam interesuję się nimi, chodzę na Festiwal Empatii. Moim zdaniem warto je wspierać na wszelkie sposoby.
    Technologia może bardzo wspierać takie działania, ich koordynowanie, realizację. A moim zdaniem dla wielu starszych ludzi technologia nie jest barierą - po prostu trzeba dobrze dla nich projektować aplikacje.